I half do it-ish, I'm not sure how to describe it, I don't print the exact picture and trace over it. Instead I just look at the picture for a very long time to know the points and lines, then in school when I'm bored I draw it but do the shadows my own way and add more things that I think fit the picture better (plus the lines aren't always 100% accurate.) all this = No wasted printed paper! Muahahaha! (somehow I still think of this way as mind tracing, because of filling in the points, but not 100% directly.)
Same here! Or when I'm drawing something, I might look at it for reference.
--
❒ Single ❒ Taken ✔ Mentally dating Once-ler You ever think REALLY hard about boredom? Commissions are (sorta) open! Check out my profile for more information!
--
❒ Single ❒ Taken ✔ Mentally dating Once-ler You ever think REALLY hard about boredom? Commissions are (sorta) open! Check out my profile for more information!
Nestly: I think there is a fine line to which tracing becomes unacceptable and just plain uncalled for, but I also believe that it is a learning curb for many young artists who are not yet confident in their artistic skills to complete pictures on their own. And I do believe it really helps build confidence and to get their feet wet in the atrist's pool.
Anyone who harshly criticizes a kid for tracing needs to get a life. So long as that person is not claiming it as their own and building drama over stolen art, it's not hurting anyone, then no big deal. Especially when credit is given. If someone were to trace my art, I'd actually be flattered that they liked my art enough to try to imitate it. As long as they don't fully claim it.
That's just my random opinion for this subject. xD
When they trace, they hurt themselves. I don't see how tracing will build confidence, because it's not the same thing as drawing, it's a dependency on other people's art. I'd understand trying to eyeball something to understand the technique used, but tracing is a waste of time.
When I was a kid, I drew like shit, but when I look back on it now, I'm still more proud of the shitty drawings I made, than the stuff I copied.
Btw, why did you prefix your comment with "Nestly:" when your username is identical and literally ten pixels above it?
Nestly: Some artists can be very discouraged about their own art at times, and tracing/referencing can help them feel motivated. It also helps learn styles and curves to drawing that you wouldn't have been able to learn before. It is never a waste of time if you can learn from it.
Same here, but that's just it. You learn either way. There's no point in putting someone down for trying to learn.
It's just an old habit and something I habitually do.
Tracing doesn't encourage analyzing technique or learning. This is especially so with the work above, where it is already highly stylized.
It's a practice of following lines and filing in spaces and is as much a tool for learning as a crayon coloring book. Anyone who is actually looking for what they need to learn from such a thing (technique, anatomy, rendering) is inhibiting their practice by tracing rather than experimenting using their own work or emulating the technique.
Think of it this way, it's like a person, who knows nothing about Japanese, speaking Japanese using an old English to Japanese dictionary. If that person tried to speak, it would be unintelligible because they are skipping grammar, pronunciation, phrasing, and etiquette. They have no idea of the usage (the 'why's) of the words because their practice never called for it, and the only thing they would have practiced is opening their mouth, just as the only thing a tracer would have practiced is making lines with a pencil. It's a waste of everyone's time.
--
I'm Doing Commissions! [link] Please check it out!
[link] <-Used to make my icon! ^.^
~dAhub <-
--
❒ Single
❒ Taken
✔ Mentally dating Once-ler
You ever think REALLY hard about boredom?
Commissions are (sorta) open! Check out my profile for more information!
--
▄██████████████▄▐█▄▄▄▄█▌
██████▌▄▌▄▐▐▌███▌▀▀██▀▀
████▄█▌▄▌▄▐▐▌▀███▄▄█▌
▄▄▄▄▄██████████████▀
spread the fail whale XD
♀ + ♀ = ♥
♂ + ♂ = ♥
♀ + ♂ = ♥
Proud member of the Okami-Club!
--
❒ Single
❒ Taken
✔ Mentally dating Once-ler
You ever think REALLY hard about boredom?
Commissions are (sorta) open! Check out my profile for more information!
Anyone who harshly criticizes a kid for tracing needs to get a life. So long as that person is not claiming it as their own and building drama over stolen art, it's not hurting anyone, then no big deal. Especially when credit is given.
If someone were to trace my art, I'd actually be flattered that they liked my art enough to try to imitate it. As long as they don't fully claim it.
That's just my random opinion for this subject. xD
--
www.happipapillon.com
I don't see how tracing will build confidence, because it's not the same thing as drawing, it's a dependency on other people's art. I'd understand trying to eyeball something to understand the technique used, but tracing is a waste of time.
When I was a kid, I drew like shit, but when I look back on it now, I'm still more proud of the shitty drawings I made, than the stuff I copied.
Btw, why did you prefix your comment with "Nestly:" when your username is identical and literally ten pixels above it?
--
dulce et utile
Same here, but that's just it. You learn either way. There's no point in putting someone down for trying to learn.
It's just an old habit and something I habitually do.
--
www.happipapillon.com
This is especially so with the work above, where it is already highly stylized.
It's a practice of following lines and filing in spaces and is as much a tool for learning as a crayon coloring book. Anyone who is actually looking for what they need to learn from such a thing (technique, anatomy, rendering) is inhibiting their practice by tracing rather than experimenting using their own work or emulating the technique.
Think of it this way, it's like a person, who knows nothing about Japanese, speaking Japanese using an old English to Japanese dictionary. If that person tried to speak, it would be unintelligible because they are skipping grammar, pronunciation, phrasing, and etiquette. They have no idea of the usage (the 'why's) of the words because their practice never called for it, and the only thing they would have practiced is opening their mouth, just as the only thing a tracer would have practiced is making lines with a pencil.
It's a waste of everyone's time.
--
dulce et utile